
The OGE was instituted by then Grand Prytanis, Leland F. Leland, in 1951 to represent the highest award given to an individual within Tau Kappa Epsilon. The primary criteria is an alumnus of the Fraternity who has contributed most significantly and materially to the advancement and welfare of TKE. The official description of the award is:
- Dedication to purpose
- Generous measure of time
- Working harmoniously with others
- Generosity of spirit
- Spirit of sacrifices
The first Order of the Golden Eagle recipient was presented to William Wilson, the oldest surviving Past Grand Prytanis & National Founder, at an October 1951 meeting because he could not be present at Conclave (where the award is given out). Since then, only 56 men have been presented the medallion and certificate. Elmer Smith (Mu-Sigma) and Christopher Hanson (Alpha-Pi) were the most recent recipients at the 2022 Conclave. The entire list is in order of acceptance:
| Order of the Golden Eagle Recipient | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| William Wilson* | Alpha | Illinois Wesleyan | 1953 |
| Dr. E.L. Theiss* | Mu | Carroll | 1955 |
| Sophus Goth* | Nu | Cal-Berkeley | 1957 |
| L.W. Tuesburg* | Alpha | Illinois Wesleyan | 1959 |
| Dr. R.C. Williams* | Alpha-Pi | George Washington | 1961 |
| Leland F. Leland* | Theta | Minnesota | 1963 |
| Harrold P. Flint* | Alpha | Illinois Wesleyan | 1965 |
| Dr. Eugene C. Beach* | Iota | Eureka | 1967 |
| Frank B. Scott* | Beta | Millikin | 1969 |
| Orval W. Diehl* | Beta | Millikin | 1971 |
| John Gehlmann* | Delta | Knox | 1973 |
| Paul Dunmire* | Alpha-Theta | Whitman | 1975 |
| William A. Quallich* | Delta-Epsilon | Cleveland State | 1977 |
| Lenwood Cochran* | Gamma-Mu | Furman | 1979 |
| William H. Wisdom* | Alpha-Xi | Drake | 1981 |
| George D. Moe* | Alpha-Sigma | North Dakota | 1982 |
| Dr. William V. Muse | Epsilon-Epsilon | Nebraska-Omaha | 1983 |
| Ronald Reagan* | Iota | Eureka | 1984 |
| Harry J. Donnelly, Jr.* | Alpha-Chi | Louisville | 1985 |
| Millard Kratochvil* | Alpha-Xi | Drake | 1985 |
| Carroll C. Hall* | Iota | Eureka | 1987 |
| Rodney Williams, Jr., CFC* | Alpha-Chi | Louisville | 1988 |
| Charles R. Walgreen, Jr.* | Upsilon | Michigan | 1989 |
| John A. Courson | Alpha-Epsilon | Monmouth | 1990 |
| Joel E. Johnson | Iota-Omicron | Wisconsin-Whitewater | 1991 |
| James C. Logan* | Xi | Washington-St.Louis | 1993 |
| Bruce B. Melchert | Beta-Theta | Missouri-Columbia | 1993 |
| James T. Kane, CFC* | Theta | Minnesota | 1995 |
| James S. Margolin | Psi | Gettysburg | 1995 |
| Robert J. Borel | Omicron | Ohio State | 1997 |
| Donald W. Peters* | Delta-Epsilon | Cleveland State | 1997 |
| Michael A. Moxley | Beta-Beta | NC State | 1999 |
| T.J. Schmitz* | Iota-Omicron | Wisconsin-Whitewater | 1999 |
| Thomas M. Castner, CFC* | Lambda-Lambda | Utica | 2001 |
| ADM John R. Fisher* | Gamma-Epsilon | Rensselaer Polytechnic | 2001 |
| Dwayne R. Woerpel, CFC* | Iota-Alpha | Wisconsin-Superior | 2001 |
| Gary A. LaBranche, CAE | Omicron | Ohio State | 2003 |
| Raymond W. Franklin | Lambda-Alpha | South Florida | 2005 |
| Lon G. Justice | Pi-Alpha | Ashland | 2005 |
| Gabriel Anaya | Alpha-Omicron | New Mexico | 2007 |
| Steven Muir | Beta-Eta | Missouri S&T | 2007 |
| Mark Fite | Delta-Xi | Miami (OH) | 2009 |
| Mark Romig, APR | Theta-Mu | New Orleans | 2009 |
| Capt. Bill Metzger | Epsilon-Nu | Wisconsin-Stevens Point | 2011 |
| Dennis “Buckwheat” Perry | Alpha-Nu | New Hampshire | 2011 |
| Bob Planck* | Epsilon-Omicron | Houston | 2011 |
| Mark Johnson | Nu-Theta | Utah | 2013 |
| Timothy Taschwer* | Epsilon-Nu | Wisconsin-Stevens Point | 2013 |
| Tim Murphy | Omicron | Ohio State | 2015 |
| Dr. Herb Songer, JRE | Alpha-Upsilon | Fort Hays State | 2015 |
| Charles Trabold* | Kappa-Kappa | Monmouth | 2015 |
| Hon. Edmund Moy | Lambda | Wisconsin | 2017 |
| Greg Woodson | Beta-Sigma | USC | 2017 |
| Hon. Bob Barr | Beta-Sigma | USC | 2019 |
| Tommy Miles* | Xi-Chi | Kennesaw State | 2019 |
| Rodney Talbot | Beta-Chi | Southern Illinois – Carbondale | 2022 |
| Elmer Smith | Mu-Sigma | Morehead State | 2022 |
| Christopher Hanson | Alpha-Pi | George Washington | 2022 |
* Denotes entered Chapter Eternal.
